54 comments

  • I think both songs are great!
    The lead and backing vocals and the music arrangements are very good.
    Very different styles, but both very good.
    It shows that Robbie can do all styles.
    I can’t decide which one is the best.

  • I like his new stuff, I think it’s great that his exploring a different sound. I LOVED Rudebox I think these songs are following in the same vein.
    Good stuff Rob and I like the beard too. :)
    Merry Christmas
    x

  • Well i am not sure what Rob is doing with his music, i really think that he needs to get rid of Steven Duffy, this music is so 80’s and its nothing but shit!! I did not buy Rudebox as i did not like anything that come off that album and to be honest after hearing these 2 songs, if this is anything to go by i do not think i will be buying the next cd!!

  • one word : great!
    bravo Robbie …We were waiting for you for a long time and now I’m sure that the next album will be fantastic !

  • shakes her head….terrible absolutely awful. i love robbies music but this just isnt good. please come back home and start making some decent music.

    Please

  • In and Out of Love – sounds old fashioned, reminds me of another song, can’t tell what the words are. Not over impressed. HOWEVER – Break America – I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE IT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! That should be No.1 all over the world :-D

  • You people call yourselves Robbie fans, and yet you cannot tell the difference between his vocals and a soundalike? Have a listen to a Robbie song, you’ll notice the difference.

  • Great two songs!!!!shows that the Robster can come and go from any musical genre he wants and be always good!!!!
    Rob: these two songs are the “official” ones by Robbie so ,like them or not, it´s the man!!!!

    Congrats, Robbie, you did it again!!!!

  • I liked both, especially Break America (the other one sounds rather old fashioned). However, I wasn’t as impressed as when I heard Feel or even Radio.
    There’s something missing in these tracks. I can’t tell what it is, but it definitely doesn’t sound Robbie.

  • SUPERB!!! WAT A COMEBACK!!! STEP ASIDE TAKE THAT…ROBBIE IS BACK! BOTH SONGS ARE AMAZING AND NEW…FORTHCOMING HIT???

  • I really like ‘In and out of love’ its got a good beat and I think the words are good – it sounds like my life!! Im not too keen on the other song. Good luck with the new songs and Merry Christmas!

  • But my favoutite is: “In And Out Of Love”…
    Well, I also like “Break America”…
    I just didnt like the Walk THis Sleigh Remix! :P

  • i think these songs are great, perfect…but i prefer in and out of love then brak amerika…robbie i´m waiting for your new album :o)

  • break america just passable but in and out of love so light weight. If this is a direction he is going in he is going to lose a lot of fans. We need harder hittinig heavier stuff. rUDEBOX WAS A ONE OFF MISTAKE DON’T REPEAT IT!!

  • Like all the other songs of him ever been the new two songs are also great. I love ‘In and Out of Love’ very much. But ‘Break America’ makes me excited and energetic. I love it the most now out of the two songs. I think Rob will rock the world including America in this new year. I will always be one of his greatest fans. He is so successful and I want him to be appreciated because he extremely deserves it. I love Rob and his every song…

  • Nobody dares to say what they really think about these two songs there not good and if he wants to come back and show take that that he’s still number 1 then he shouldnt make music like this hope there not on the album he needs to look at his old albums and make more music like that.

  • I think they both sound great, “Break America” is a great rap/hip,hop track and “In And Out Of Love” is a great pop track. I say good for you to Robbie for trying out different styles of song, it’s always good to do something different and venture out now and again rather than doing one style. To me Robbie voice is well suited to those styles not just rock and power ballads and pop as he’s done previously. I am looking forward to his new album.

  • i really love robbie´s music..but these songs…i dont like them much…

    In fact i Totally agree with this comment above:

    “break america just passable but in and out of love so light weight. If this is a direction he is going in he is going to lose a lot of fans. We need harder hittinig heavier stuff. rUDEBOX WAS A ONE OFF MISTAKE DON’T REPEAT IT!!”

  • Have you seen Star stories? When robbie sings that song of fat twat sounds like”break america” ..not a serious song i think

  • I think that “In and out of love” is similar to Lovelight… but Robbie did a big mistake with Rudebox and now this music is similar… I don’t know what is he thinking!
    I have all his CDs and I want to Rock-Robbie… I want his songs like the songs from Escapology…
    P.D:Sorry my english.

  • I don`t think they are bad but I really miss his old albums and I just can`t believe he did the same mistake again as he did with his last album RUDEBOX:(
    But I still love you rob

  • in and out of love is better ,the music style of break america is so 80’s,i don’t like that.

  • Back to the 80’s again. I enjoyed both, but Rob needs to stop thinking about what he is writing and write from the heart.

  • as a big fan of Robbie i am excited to hear his new songs, but these 2 songs are not quite good…

    any more songs? Collin from DUBAI, UAE

  • Absolutely LOVE your sense of humour. Your’ll really break America with that one Robbie.
    In & out of love, OK.

  • He is amazing!i love everything about him….but EScapology and Intensive Care are my favourites cdsHappy birthday Robb I love you

  • it’s interesting! he’s singing about how he feel’s and that’s great. Love you Robbie! You are a great talent.

  • Robbie i am a huge fan,,but don’t like it at all…sorry..very wishy washy.. Yours songs are usually from somewhere far deeper..I want to help..got one for you rob if your interested..xx

  • Happy Valentines Day Rob

    Had lunch with you today, yeah Lunch with Robbie Williams! on Max, loved every minute of it.

  • God I LOVE ROBBIE! But those songs are seriously shithouse. WTF is going on with that man. Robbie, pull your head out of your arse and write something good…. PLEASE…for the love of god………put me out of my misery.

  • The songs are good,but they aren’t something special.Robbie has fascinating songs,but these…you can’t remember them.This isn’t Robbie’s music style.
    I`m waiting for something really godd and remembering.

  • Your music was fantastic until you did Rudebox and this crap! Get a new music partner!!

  • I am a huge fan of Robbie’s from the States and these songs are not good unfortunately. I loved Escapology and his older songs. Robbie, please re-think your energy.

  • What a mistake, can this really be the same person that provided albums such as Life thru a lens, I’ve Been Expecting you, Sing When your winning, and the best Escapology….?

    Who is guiding Robbie now… If it is this Stephen Duffy then get rid, there is a reason this guy has no songs out there himself..

    He’s ruining you Rob, There are great artists out there that blend well with certain writers who together they are genius. Look at Elton & Taupin, Lennon & McCartney, Robbie and Chambers…. get back to it, it’s what we like, since Escapology you have gone downhill and it’s losing you fans. I regretted buying Intensive Care and further regretted buying Rudebox… Don’t make the same mistake and bring out more tosh… I won’t be making the same mistake again… These two songs are basic crap regurgitated from the 80’s get Duffy out of your life!!!

  • i think robs new songs are great ive been a fan since life thru a lens and loved each and every song hes every done can wait for the new album

Comments are closed.